Singing to the Herd
Two Hours in the Dark, Circling the Cattle
The round-up worked from before dawn until dark. Then the hardest shift began. Each night, riders took turns guarding the bedded herd, ready for anything that might send it running.
T.R. rode that guard on the Little Missouri, and he wrote about it twice: in Ranch Life and the Hunting-Trail (1888) and again in An Autobiography (1913).
Key Facts
| The shift | About two hours a rider, through the night |
|---|---|
| The riders | Two at a time, circling the herd in opposite directions |
| Why sing | A human voice seemed to quiet restless cattle |
| The danger | A stampede in the dark |
"The Herd at Night," by Frederic Remington, from T.R.'s Ranch Life and the Hunting-Trail (1888). (Public domain)
In T.R.'s Words, 1888
In the chapter "The Round-Up" of Ranch Life and the Hunting-Trail, T.R. explained what happened once the herd settled for the night:
When finally they have lain down and are chewing their cud or slumbering, the two night guards begin riding round them in opposite ways, often, on very dark nights, calling or singing to them, as the sound of the human voice on such occasions seems to have a tendency to quiet them.
Frederic Remington drew the scene for the book's first edition.
Looking Back, 1913
Twenty-five years later, in the chapter "In Cowboy Land" of An Autobiography, T.R. remembered the shift with affection:
When utterly tired, it was hard to have to get up for one's trick at night herd. Nevertheless, on ordinary nights the two hours round the cattle in the still darkness were pleasant.
He wrote, too, that the punchers on night guard rode round the cattle in reverse directions, calling and singing to them if the beasts seemed restless.
Theodore Roosevelt in his buckskin hunting suit, about 1885.
"In a Stampede," by Frederic Remington, from T.R.'s Ranch Life and the Hunting-Trail (1888). (Public domain)
The Cowhand Who Quoted Walter Scott
One stormy night on the round-up, as the wind rose and the rain turned to sheets, one of T.R.'s men looked toward the herd. T.R. told the story in Ranch Life and the Hunting-Trail:
One of my men, an iron-faced personage, whom no one would ever have dreamed had a weakness for poetry, looked towards the plain where the cattle were, and remarked, 'I guess there's "racing and chasing on Cannobie Lea" now, sure.'
The line comes from Walter Scott's ballad "Lochinvar." The cattle were already drifting before the storm, and the men ran for their horses.
Cattle on the Move, on Film
No one filmed T.R.'s round-ups; motion pictures arrived a few years later. This short film from Thomas Edison's company, made in Oklahoma Territory in 1904, shows the same kind of work: riders driving a herd of cattle.
The film is silent. Imagine the riders' voices carrying over the herd.
What His Neighbors Remembered
Hermann Hagedorn interviewed T.R.'s Dakota neighbors for Roosevelt in the Bad Lands (1921). They remembered T.R. on guard "humming some eerie lullaby," always the same tune. They remembered Howard Eaton's banjo around the round-up fire, and Bill Dantz, who knew a hundred songs by heart.
One of the songs those riders carried up the trail is "The Old Chisholm Trail," with its complaint: "I swear, by god, I'll never night-herd again."
Sung by Frank Goodwyn at Falfurrias, Texas, April 30, 1939.
Recorded by John A. and Ruby T. Lomax. Library of Congress, American Folklife Center
Hear It Live in Medora
The cowboy's songs never really stopped. Every Memorial Day weekend, ranchers from across the Dakotas share their poems and songs at the Dakota Cowboy Poetry Gathering in the Medora Community Center, a few minutes from the Library.
Continue Reading
- Roosevelt and John Lomax—The letter behind Cowboy Songs
- The Songs—Ballads from the 1910 book, with recordings
- Dakota Cowboy Poetry Gathering—The tradition lives on in Medora
- Frontier Life in the 1880s Badlands—Sixteen hours in the saddle on the round-up
- Songs of the Cow Country—The hub for this story
Primary Sources
- Ranch Life and the Hunting-Trail (1888)—T.R.'s account of the round-up
- An Autobiography (1913)—the chapter "In Cowboy Land"
- Cowboy Songs and Other Frontier Ballads (1910)
- T.R.'s letters to John Lomax at the Theodore Roosevelt Center
From the Archives
Explore original photographs, documents and illustrations in the Theodore Roosevelt Center Digital Library.
Recommended Reading
- Roosevelt in the Bad Lands by Hermann Hagedorn (1921)
- Cowboy Songs and Other Frontier Ballads, collected by John A. Lomax (1910)
- Ranch Life and the Hunting-Trail by Theodore Roosevelt (1888)