Alice Hathaway Lee Roosevelt: Theodore's First Love

A Chance Meeting at Chestnut Hill

The story of Alice Hathaway Lee Roosevelt begins on an October evening in 1878 at a dinner party in Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts. A young Harvard student named Theodore Roosevelt attended this gathering, expecting an ordinary social event. Instead, he encountered a woman who would transform his life—at least for a brief, luminous time. Alice was seventeen years old, with honey-colored hair, pale blue-gray eyes, and a grace that captivated Theodore immediately and completely. He fell in love at first sight, a condition that would consume the next few years of his life.

Theodore had always been intense, competitive, and driven. But Alice awakened something in him beyond ambition: romantic devotion. He began calling at her home. He arranged "accidental" encounters on Boston streets. His letters to her were filled with an almost desperate earnestness—too eager, perhaps, for a girl accustomed to more practiced suitors. Alice was amused by his devotion, touched by his sincerity, but hesitant to return his feelings with equal fervor. The awkward young man with the prominent teeth and the fierce blue eyes seemed somehow too much, too earnest, too all-consuming in his affections.

Portrait of a young woman with upswept hair in a dark patterned dress

Alice Hathaway Lee, whom Theodore Roosevelt met at Chestnut Hill in 1878 and courted while a student at Harvard. (Theodore Roosevelt Collection, Harvard College Library)

Head-and-shoulders portrait of a young Theodore Roosevelt with side whiskers

Theodore Roosevelt as a Harvard student around the time of his engagement to Alice Lee. (Library of Congress)

Persistence Rewarded: The Engagement

But persistence—a Roosevelt family trait—eventually won Alice over. By the winter of 1879, she was beginning to return his affection. By early 1880, they had reached an understanding. On January 25, 1880, Theodore formally betrothed himself to Alice. The engagement was announced publicly on February 16, 1880. Theodore's joy was uncontained and almost alarming in its intensity. He had found, he believed, the completion of himself, the woman who would make his life whole. His political activities in the Assembly would soon demand his attention, but Alice remained at the center of his world during these years of early ambition and romantic devotion.

Theodore's letters from this period express a romantic devotion that might seem excessive even for a young man in love. "See, I told you that you were my sunshine," he wrote, articulating a sense that Alice was not merely a partner but the very light of his existence. For a man who would later become famous for his control and his strength, there was something almost vulnerable in his dependence on Alice's presence in his life. She had become essential—not supplementary, but fundamental to his sense of himself.

A Brief Marriage, a Beautiful Home

Theodore and Alice married on October 27, 1880—Theodore's twenty-second birthday—at the Unitarian Church in Brookline, Massachusetts. In photographs from their wedding day and the months that followed, Theodore appears almost unrecognizably happy. His usual intensity has transformed into something approaching serenity. He had his Harvard degree. He had his book—The Naval War of 1812—in progress. He had Alice. He had his whole life stretching ahead of him, full of promise and light.

The young couple established themselves in a modest townhouse at 6 West 57th Street in New York City, near Fifth Avenue. Theodore began law school at Columbia, though politics interested him far more than legal studies. Alice settled into the role of a young married woman of the merchant class, keeping house, expecting soon to become a mother. In the photographs and family accounts of this period, Alice appears content, beautiful, secure in her husband's devotion. Theodore threw himself into political organizing with his characteristic enthusiasm, attending meetings of the Republican organization in the Twenty-first Assembly District, speaking passionately about reform and good government.

Two seated young women and a standing young man in a studio portrait

Alice Lee Roosevelt (seated) with Rose and Theodore Roosevelt in a studio portrait from the early 1880s. (Theodore Roosevelt Collection, Harvard College Library)

Young woman in a dark buttoned dress standing beside a small table

Alice Lee Roosevelt, Theodore Roosevelt's first wife, who died in February 1884 two days after giving birth to their daughter. (Theodore Roosevelt Collection, Harvard College Library)

The Promise of Motherhood, Cut Short

In December 1883 or January 1884, Alice became pregnant. Theodore was overjoyed. He would have a child, an heir, a continuation of himself into the future. As Alice's due date approached in February 1884, Theodore's anticipation grew. On February 12, 1884, at 8:30 PM, after a difficult but successful labor, Alice gave birth to a daughter, also named Alice Lee Roosevelt. The infant weighed 8.75 pounds, appeared robust and healthy, and had her mother's pale eyes and delicate features. Theodore was overjoyed. He had his daughter. He had his wife. The future seemed infinitely bright.

But joy was about to shatter into tragedy. In the days following childbirth, Alice developed Bright's disease—now understood as a form of acute kidney failure brought on by the stress and strain of childbirth. The condition, in the 1880s, had no effective treatment. Kidney failure was invariably fatal. Alice, at twenty-two years old, was dying. On February 14, 1884, at approximately 2 PM, just two days after giving birth to her daughter, Alice died.

The Light Goes Out

Theodore received the news while in Albany, attending to Assembly business. He left immediately for New York. He arrived at his house on 6 West 57th Street at 11:30 PM on February 13, not yet aware of the full tragedy—for on the very same day, early in the morning while Alice was dying downstairs, his mother Martha "Mittie" Bulloch Roosevelt had died of typhoid fever upstairs. Both women—his wife and his mother—died in the same house, on the same day, hours apart. The coincidence seemed almost diabolical in its cruelty.

Theodore's response to Alice's death was profound and lasting. His diary entry for February 14, 1884, recorded his devastation in seven words: "The light has gone out of my life." He made a deliberate choice never to speak Alice's name again. In his autobiography, published decades later, he made no mention of her. It was as if, through an act of will, he had attempted to erase her from his life narrative, to deny that the light had ever been there so that its extinguishing would be less devastating.

Soft-focus oval portrait of a young woman in profile

Alice Hathaway Lee Roosevelt, whose death Theodore marked with the words "the light has gone out of my life." (Theodore Roosevelt Collection, Harvard College Library)

Memory, Silence, and Enduring Love

The wound never fully healed. For the rest of his life, there were moments when grief broke through Theodore's carefully maintained emotional control—when something would remind him of Alice, and the loss would come flooding back, still sharp after decades. His closest friends suspected that some part of him—the romantic idealist, the boy who had believed in perfect happiness—died with Alice on February 14, 1884. He would remarry, in 1886, to Edith Kermit Carow, who would be an excellent wife and devoted partner for the remaining decades of his life. But Alice remained his first love, the soulmate of his youth, the woman for whom he felt an intensity of devotion that he never quite allowed himself to express again.

Alice's infant daughter, placed in the care of Theodore's sister Bamie, grew into one of the most fascinating women in American history—Alice Roosevelt Longworth, the "Princess Alice" of the press, known for her wit, her independence, and her political influence. She would live to be 96 years old, outliving her father by more than 40 years, and would preserve his memory with fierce devotion. But she never knew her mother. The one thing she inherited from Alice was her appearance—the pale eyes, the slight figure, the luminous quality that had captivated Theodore Roosevelt on that October evening in Chestnut Hill so long ago.

Continue Reading

From the Archives

Explore original photographs, documents, and illustrations related to this topic in the Theodore Roosevelt Center Digital Library.

Recommended Reading

  • Theodore Roosevelt: A Life, Nathan Miller, 2011, ISBN 978-0062078543
  • Mornings on Horseback: The Story of an Extraordinary Family, a Vanished Way of Life and the Unique Child Who Became Theodore Roosevelt, David McCullough, 1981, ISBN 978-0671629694
  • Alice: Alice Roosevelt Longworth, from White House Princess to Washington Power Broker, Stacy A. Cordery, 2007, ISBN 978-0670034772